I've just returned from a meeting of the Oxford University Labour Club, where Harriet Harman was speaking to students. The South London MP was elected deputy leader of her party last year in front of a surprised and dismayed conference hall, but whatever people think about Harman, she's a decent public speaker. She had a good rapport with the 40-strong audience, and although I couldn't find much to agree with in her talk, she at least managed to say it all without sending me to sleep, which is a start.
She spoke initially about immigration policy, but her main aim was actually to chivvy along the young Labour activists ahead of next week's crucial local elections. The latest YouGov poll with its apparent 18-point Tory lead hasn't gone down too well with the grassroots, and Harman wanted to tell them that the situation is far, far better than the facts suggest.
The more time I spend following politics, the more convinced I become that you can spin literally any story in any direction, if only you're brazen enough to keep a straight face whilst you do it. The Labour party in Oxford are campaigning against the minority Lib Dem administration because apparently, below-inflation rises in council tax are putting public services at threat. (And there was me thinking that Lib Dem councillors had simply delivered good value for money ...) Harperson was equally brazen with her spin today. I have no idea how she managed to convince a roomful of students that the economy was in rude health, and that an 18-point deficit in the polls was certain to translate into a clear victory and a 4th term in office at the next general election - but somehow she managed.
In the question and answers session, I asked her whether she'd feel more comfortable going into coalition with the Tories or with the Lib Dems, should there be a hung parliament next time round. I'm fed up of commentators asking this question relentlessly to the Lib Dems, but never putting the same question to the other two parties. I was quite keen to see what the Labour deputy leader would have to say on the subject.
I was actually quite surprised to get a straight answer: she prefers us. She feels we're ideologically closer to her, and wishes the Lib Dems would just join her party so that the combined political "left" could just get on with fighting the Tories.
That answer should be a serious warning to the odd few Lib Dems who fall into very much the same trap. The idea that we're part of a wider progressive movement in British politics, with the common aim of beating the Tories, is exactly the way the Labour Party top brass want us to feel. The real situation is very different - rather than forming a progressive alliance with Labour against the Tories, we need to seek to build a liberal alliance to battle against two authoritarian, instrusive and statist parties that are, in their different ways, just as bad as each other. Labour's commitment to social justice can't justify their invasive style of government; the fact that they share many of our ends can't justify their means.
I have to give the Labour Club members a mention. The students did give Harman a genuinely hard time, with tough, intelligent and analytical questions on the 10p tax band, party political funding, and especially the scandal of the Saudi arms deal. I was very impressed with the young woman who asked why on earth we were going to such great lengths to preserve good commercial relations with Saudi Arabia in spite of their atrocious record on human rights. I don't often go along to the Labour Club, but when I do, I'm usually very impressed by the standard of the debate there. Credit where credit is due.
Showing posts with label hung Parliament. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hung Parliament. Show all posts
Friday, 25 April 2008
Monday, 10 March 2008
Clegg ditches Lib Dem commitment to PR
Yesterday, on the quiet, Nick Clegg scrapped the Liberal Democrats' long-standing commitment to reform Britain's electoral system. So it appears, anyway, from his speech to the party's spring conference in Liverpool. He may not have meant to do it, but the following paragraph, buried in the middle of a 50-minute note-free oration, destroys the long-held liberal hope of a fairer voting system:
The day before I was elected leader, Mr Cameron suggested we join them, he talked about a “progressive alliance”. This talk of alliances comes up a lot, doesn’t it? Everyone wants to be in our gang. So I want to make something very clear today. Will I ever join a Conservative government? No. Will I ever join a Labour government? No. I will never allow the Liberal Democrats to be a mere annex to another party's agenda.
I may be very naïve, but I had always been under the impression that Lib Dems were in favour of coalition government, on a matter of principle. Coalitions are supposed to be more effective, more representative, and more democratic, especially in a country where even the most popular political party can only muster 35% of the vote. Democracy doesn't mean the largest minority group in society getting to steamroller their views over the heads of the rest, and Lib Dems have always rather liked the idea of forcing parties to work together. But here's Clegg, perhaps two years before a general election, ruling out a coalition with either of the other two. What on earth is he doing?
Yesterday's announcement fatally undermines our most identifiable policy position. If we refuse to work constructively with parties that don't share our ideology, yet still support proportional representation, what on earth are people supposed to conclude, if not that we want to see permanent minority government? That surely can't be tenable.
Now to be fair to Clegg (and he's had a rough time lately), I can think of at least one excellent reason for this announcement: the coalition question always screws us over. In the buildup to an election, all it takes us for somebody to ask us who we'd rather go into coalition with, and our campaign goes off the rails. We've never yet found a satisfactory answer.
If we declare a preference for one of the other parties - say, Labour - we throw away our ability to set an independent liberal agenda. Suddenly, there's no point in voting Lib Dem: if people know we're only going to prop up Labour anyway, they might as well vote for Labour in the first place, if they support them, or the Tories if they don't.
But suppose we decide to keep our independence, and refuse to declare a preference for Labour or the Tories. Suddenly, we become the sleazy party of backroom deals, who've already sewn up the result of the next election behind closed doors, without ever consulting the people.
And suppose we say, quite sensibly, that we'll wait until the next general election, chat to the other parties, and try to thrash out the most liberal policy programme we can under the circumstances, without any predetermined favourite. Well, people switch off and don't listen. That sort of message takes a bit of explaining, and is almost impossible to get into a catchy soundbite.
It seems whichever way we turn, we can't win. And so Nick Clegg is going for option four: to refuse to go into government with either Labour or the Tories, instead promising us the nebulous waffle of "a new type of government ... based on pluralism instead of one party rule" - frankly, I struggle to see how that ambition could ever be put into practice without a coalition-based system, even if it's expressed in English so hazy as to require fog-lights.
Don't get me wrong: I sympathise with Clegg a great deal. PR is one of those awkward areas where we have a very coherent and justified position, but one which is too nuanced to be explained simply, and which can be undermined with depressing ease by one well-aimed jibe from our opponents. But Clegg needs to watch out. There's no point countering those jibes if the only way to do it is to sacrifice all the coherence that made our position worthwhile in the first place.
The day before I was elected leader, Mr Cameron suggested we join them, he talked about a “progressive alliance”. This talk of alliances comes up a lot, doesn’t it? Everyone wants to be in our gang. So I want to make something very clear today. Will I ever join a Conservative government? No. Will I ever join a Labour government? No. I will never allow the Liberal Democrats to be a mere annex to another party's agenda.
I may be very naïve, but I had always been under the impression that Lib Dems were in favour of coalition government, on a matter of principle. Coalitions are supposed to be more effective, more representative, and more democratic, especially in a country where even the most popular political party can only muster 35% of the vote. Democracy doesn't mean the largest minority group in society getting to steamroller their views over the heads of the rest, and Lib Dems have always rather liked the idea of forcing parties to work together. But here's Clegg, perhaps two years before a general election, ruling out a coalition with either of the other two. What on earth is he doing?
Yesterday's announcement fatally undermines our most identifiable policy position. If we refuse to work constructively with parties that don't share our ideology, yet still support proportional representation, what on earth are people supposed to conclude, if not that we want to see permanent minority government? That surely can't be tenable.
Now to be fair to Clegg (and he's had a rough time lately), I can think of at least one excellent reason for this announcement: the coalition question always screws us over. In the buildup to an election, all it takes us for somebody to ask us who we'd rather go into coalition with, and our campaign goes off the rails. We've never yet found a satisfactory answer.
If we declare a preference for one of the other parties - say, Labour - we throw away our ability to set an independent liberal agenda. Suddenly, there's no point in voting Lib Dem: if people know we're only going to prop up Labour anyway, they might as well vote for Labour in the first place, if they support them, or the Tories if they don't.
But suppose we decide to keep our independence, and refuse to declare a preference for Labour or the Tories. Suddenly, we become the sleazy party of backroom deals, who've already sewn up the result of the next election behind closed doors, without ever consulting the people.
And suppose we say, quite sensibly, that we'll wait until the next general election, chat to the other parties, and try to thrash out the most liberal policy programme we can under the circumstances, without any predetermined favourite. Well, people switch off and don't listen. That sort of message takes a bit of explaining, and is almost impossible to get into a catchy soundbite.
It seems whichever way we turn, we can't win. And so Nick Clegg is going for option four: to refuse to go into government with either Labour or the Tories, instead promising us the nebulous waffle of "a new type of government ... based on pluralism instead of one party rule" - frankly, I struggle to see how that ambition could ever be put into practice without a coalition-based system, even if it's expressed in English so hazy as to require fog-lights.
Don't get me wrong: I sympathise with Clegg a great deal. PR is one of those awkward areas where we have a very coherent and justified position, but one which is too nuanced to be explained simply, and which can be undermined with depressing ease by one well-aimed jibe from our opponents. But Clegg needs to watch out. There's no point countering those jibes if the only way to do it is to sacrifice all the coherence that made our position worthwhile in the first place.
Labels:
coalitions,
conference,
hung Parliament,
Nick Clegg
Thursday, 6 September 2007
The coalition question. Again.
Mark Oaten won't have made himself very popular today. In a very disjointed article in the Times, he argues that a hung parliament now looks likely; that if it happens, the Liberal Democrats should agree to enter a coalition with whichever party is the larger; that we should therefore be prepared to ally with the Conservative Party if necessary; and that the Tories aren't really so different from us anyway.
Nothing derails the Lib Dems more effectively than speculation about a hung parliament. We need a well thought-out, reasonable, and above all, consistent answer. The fact that the question keeps coming up, again and again, shows how badly we usually tackle it. And of all the dreadful attempts, this one by Oaten has to be the worst I've ever seen.
The premise behind the article is shaky to start with - we are not staring a hung parliament in the face. Even taking the figures from the Times' poll on Tuesday, Brown would still have a majority. The last hung parliament was fully a third of a century ago; the one before that was in the year my granny was born. Under Britain's rather eccentric voting system, they come along very rarely, and when they do come, they don't last long. We need to let people know that the idea of a hung parliament isn't credible, and that it only gets so much airtime because the other parties know it gives us a headache.
But just suppose Oaten's right. Brown calls a general election, the vote splits three ways, and any possible combination of Labour, Tory and Lib Dem could form a government. Would we really be right to insist on dealing only with the larger of the other two parties?
The largest party in Parliament clearly deserves to have the first go. However, any grouping with a majority of the seats can legitimately form a government. Talking to either party would be morally acceptable. The guiding factor should be political principles, not numbers. That doesn't mean it would be unthinkable to ally with the Tories - but if we did, it would be because we managed to reach a genuine agreement, rather than because they had a half a dozen MPs more than Labour.
Mark Oaten believes we have plenty of common ground with the Tories. He arrives at this conclusion because "recent votes have seen the Lib Dems walk through the House of Commons lobby with the Tories more often than with Labour in protecting liberal values." Perhaps. But then again, perhaps it's because we're both parties of opposition, in a system where politicians can have a nuanced debate in the chamber, but are forced to make a polar choice in the lobbies.
I know I keep banging on about the importance of the Lib Dems being independent, but it's so crucial, it just can't be overstated. If we give the slightest hint that we're endorsing the Tories over the Labour, we give both of them an open invitation to squeeze us like a floppy yellow sponge. Cameron can say "why vote Lib Dem, when you can vote for the real thing?" Brown can say "if you dislike Cameron (and who doesn't?), Labour are the only choice." Exactly the same process will happen in reverse if we appear to be endorsing Labour.
The only way to get rid of the coalition question is to refuse, point blank, to give any preference to either party. Instead, we have to pledge to sit down with both of them, in the event of a hung parliament, and try our best to agree on a Queen's Speech that would be true to our liberal principles. We have to promise not to enter government, with either party, unless we can agree on a programme of legislation that doesn't betray our manifesto, and where every compromise we make, for the greater good, is explained honestly and openly to the public. That would be the most responsible way to navigate a hung parliament, should it ever occur, and far more effective than some pre-determined strategy based on crude numbers (Oaten) or personal chemistry (Ashdown and Campbell).
Perhaps the best way to turn this back on Labour and the Tories is to point how close together they now are, and argue that they'd do best to form a German-style grand coalition with each other. It's a very cheeky answer. But it's no cheekier than our opponents branding us as opportunistic, for hypothetically making the wrong choice in a non-existent situation.
Nothing derails the Lib Dems more effectively than speculation about a hung parliament. We need a well thought-out, reasonable, and above all, consistent answer. The fact that the question keeps coming up, again and again, shows how badly we usually tackle it. And of all the dreadful attempts, this one by Oaten has to be the worst I've ever seen.
The premise behind the article is shaky to start with - we are not staring a hung parliament in the face. Even taking the figures from the Times' poll on Tuesday, Brown would still have a majority. The last hung parliament was fully a third of a century ago; the one before that was in the year my granny was born. Under Britain's rather eccentric voting system, they come along very rarely, and when they do come, they don't last long. We need to let people know that the idea of a hung parliament isn't credible, and that it only gets so much airtime because the other parties know it gives us a headache.
But just suppose Oaten's right. Brown calls a general election, the vote splits three ways, and any possible combination of Labour, Tory and Lib Dem could form a government. Would we really be right to insist on dealing only with the larger of the other two parties?
The largest party in Parliament clearly deserves to have the first go. However, any grouping with a majority of the seats can legitimately form a government. Talking to either party would be morally acceptable. The guiding factor should be political principles, not numbers. That doesn't mean it would be unthinkable to ally with the Tories - but if we did, it would be because we managed to reach a genuine agreement, rather than because they had a half a dozen MPs more than Labour.
Mark Oaten believes we have plenty of common ground with the Tories. He arrives at this conclusion because "recent votes have seen the Lib Dems walk through the House of Commons lobby with the Tories more often than with Labour in protecting liberal values." Perhaps. But then again, perhaps it's because we're both parties of opposition, in a system where politicians can have a nuanced debate in the chamber, but are forced to make a polar choice in the lobbies.
I know I keep banging on about the importance of the Lib Dems being independent, but it's so crucial, it just can't be overstated. If we give the slightest hint that we're endorsing the Tories over the Labour, we give both of them an open invitation to squeeze us like a floppy yellow sponge. Cameron can say "why vote Lib Dem, when you can vote for the real thing?" Brown can say "if you dislike Cameron (and who doesn't?), Labour are the only choice." Exactly the same process will happen in reverse if we appear to be endorsing Labour.
The only way to get rid of the coalition question is to refuse, point blank, to give any preference to either party. Instead, we have to pledge to sit down with both of them, in the event of a hung parliament, and try our best to agree on a Queen's Speech that would be true to our liberal principles. We have to promise not to enter government, with either party, unless we can agree on a programme of legislation that doesn't betray our manifesto, and where every compromise we make, for the greater good, is explained honestly and openly to the public. That would be the most responsible way to navigate a hung parliament, should it ever occur, and far more effective than some pre-determined strategy based on crude numbers (Oaten) or personal chemistry (Ashdown and Campbell).
Perhaps the best way to turn this back on Labour and the Tories is to point how close together they now are, and argue that they'd do best to form a German-style grand coalition with each other. It's a very cheeky answer. But it's no cheekier than our opponents branding us as opportunistic, for hypothetically making the wrong choice in a non-existent situation.
Monday, 3 September 2007
Matthew Taylor's appointment - Ming should put his foot down!
Liberal Democrat MP Matthew Taylor has accepted an invitation from the Prime Minister to lead a major review of land-use policy, with the aim of improving affordable housing in rural areas. Menzies Campbell welcomed the appointment, claiming it as a victory for Lib Dem policy, and as an admission of defeat by the Government:
I am delighted that Gordon Brown has once again recognised the knowledge and experience that Liberal Democrats have to offer in tackling major policy challenges that the Government has proved unable to solve.
His analysis is optimistic at best, and at worst, appallingly naïve. Gordon Brown doesn't believe he's failed, and he isn't particularly interested in taking the Lib Dems' advice, either. Ming should know - he gave the PM some pretty sound foreign policy advice last week, and was sent packing.
It doesn't take a genius to work out what Brown's up to. His announcement came at the climax of a speech this morning, where he promised a "new politics" based on consensus, and made lots of noises about the "centre ground". His political strategy revolves around defending the centre, whilst appearing open-minded, listening, and humble. This tactic is absolutely key to revitalising a 10-year-old Government which people were beginning to get thoroughly sick of. Brown will do whatever it takes to make the new image work, even if that means suffering the odd Tory or Lib Dem in his team.
Or to put it more bluntly: Brown is cynically using the Lib Dems. He's allowing them to get a little taste of power, but being careful to offer them jobs where there's already considerable cross-party consensus, and where there's little chance of them setting their own distinctive, liberal agenda. In return for pretty minor concessions, Brown gets to portray himself as a centrist and a moderate; he gets to look diplomatic and broad-minded; and he gets to tap into the tremendous public goodwill towards the Liberal Democrats.
He knows we're likely to accept whatever biscuits he chucks our way. As the third party, opposing a Government with a fair majority, we have precious little chance to change Britain. We hate being a glorified think tank, and are frustrated by the remote chances of getting into power anytime soon. We're ambitious - rightly so - and any of us would jump at the opportunity to make a tangible difference, no matter how specific the brief.
The danger is this: the rubbing-off can work both ways. As Labour can benefit from the Lib Dems' political position, and the general perception of us as a bunch of fairly decent people, they can also begin to offload their own baggage onto us.
More to the point, the eccentricities of the British electoral system put us in a uniquely awkward position. Our vote gets squeezed from both sides, and speculation about our relationships with the other parties, especially in the event of a hung parliament, can entirely derail us. Any form of collaboration with the Government, especially when they have a good majority of their own, could go very wrong indeed.
Our independence is far more important than the opportunity of improving rural housing, however worthy a cause that may be. At a time of intellectually stale politics, and a n ever-decreasing gap between the Government and the Official Opposition, our free-thinking and distinctive voice is more vital than ever. Ming needs to put his foot down. Active Lib Dems in elected positions should be working for their party, or for parliament, but not the PM.
I am delighted that Gordon Brown has once again recognised the knowledge and experience that Liberal Democrats have to offer in tackling major policy challenges that the Government has proved unable to solve.
His analysis is optimistic at best, and at worst, appallingly naïve. Gordon Brown doesn't believe he's failed, and he isn't particularly interested in taking the Lib Dems' advice, either. Ming should know - he gave the PM some pretty sound foreign policy advice last week, and was sent packing.
It doesn't take a genius to work out what Brown's up to. His announcement came at the climax of a speech this morning, where he promised a "new politics" based on consensus, and made lots of noises about the "centre ground". His political strategy revolves around defending the centre, whilst appearing open-minded, listening, and humble. This tactic is absolutely key to revitalising a 10-year-old Government which people were beginning to get thoroughly sick of. Brown will do whatever it takes to make the new image work, even if that means suffering the odd Tory or Lib Dem in his team.
Or to put it more bluntly: Brown is cynically using the Lib Dems. He's allowing them to get a little taste of power, but being careful to offer them jobs where there's already considerable cross-party consensus, and where there's little chance of them setting their own distinctive, liberal agenda. In return for pretty minor concessions, Brown gets to portray himself as a centrist and a moderate; he gets to look diplomatic and broad-minded; and he gets to tap into the tremendous public goodwill towards the Liberal Democrats.
He knows we're likely to accept whatever biscuits he chucks our way. As the third party, opposing a Government with a fair majority, we have precious little chance to change Britain. We hate being a glorified think tank, and are frustrated by the remote chances of getting into power anytime soon. We're ambitious - rightly so - and any of us would jump at the opportunity to make a tangible difference, no matter how specific the brief.
The danger is this: the rubbing-off can work both ways. As Labour can benefit from the Lib Dems' political position, and the general perception of us as a bunch of fairly decent people, they can also begin to offload their own baggage onto us.
More to the point, the eccentricities of the British electoral system put us in a uniquely awkward position. Our vote gets squeezed from both sides, and speculation about our relationships with the other parties, especially in the event of a hung parliament, can entirely derail us. Any form of collaboration with the Government, especially when they have a good majority of their own, could go very wrong indeed.
Our independence is far more important than the opportunity of improving rural housing, however worthy a cause that may be. At a time of intellectually stale politics, and a n ever-decreasing gap between the Government and the Official Opposition, our free-thinking and distinctive voice is more vital than ever. Ming needs to put his foot down. Active Lib Dems in elected positions should be working for their party, or for parliament, but not the PM.
Thursday, 15 March 2007
A reply from Ming
Last week, I criticised our handling of the hung Parliament question, and suggested a much more honest and direct approach. In a moment of cheekiness unparalleled in the history of the Lib Dems, I wrote a "speech" for Sir Ming to deliver, to put the whole question to bed. To add the icing on the cheeky cake (which takes some doing), I sent him the link!
Our technologically-savvy leader, or one of his technologically-savvy office staff, has very kindly written me a response, via Facebook. For readers who aren't familiar with this august website, it's a social networking system, originally for students but now open to everyone. Several of our MPs have Facebook profiles, which may well help with campaigning.
So what did the pinstriped radical have to say for himself?
Firstly, he assured me that he wasn't interested in campaigning for a hung Parliament or a coalition, and that he was still focused on maximising our votes and seats. I agree with him, and I'm glad to hear him say so - but it doesn't solve the problem. Whether he intended it or not, his Conference speech has been widely seen as a coalition overture to Labour. However sincerely he means it when he talks about "maximum votes", that line will no longer stop speculation. Not in the way that it did a fortnight ago.
In his reply, Ming quoted a section from his Conference speech, and complained that it hadn't been taken into account by the newspapers in their analysis. It comes just before the infamous five tests:
And now we are faced with the prospect of Gordon Brown as prime minister.
As far as it goes, this is all true. But I would direct Sir Ming to Stephen Tall's excellent article on the subject. Stephen points out that Ming "clumsily set out five tests for Labour’s Gordon Brown to prove his prime ministerial worthiness, but scornfully dismissed David Cameron’s Tories in just three words".
Ming may well claim to have provided a balance between courting Brown and criticising his record - but what happened to the correct balance between criticism of Labour, and criticism of the Tories? That's the balance he got wrong, and that's what led to the damaging speculation.
I suspect (and I have no inside knowledge) that Ming is very unimpressed by David Cameron, and intensely dislikes him. But I worry that he lets his personal contempt colour his political judgement. As my favourite fluffy elephant rightly pointed out, instead of writing him off in three words, Ming should have set some tests for Cameron as well:
The true tests for the Conservatories surely should be the SAME, but with ONE MORE: have some policies so that we can TELL whether you have changed or not!
On the one hand, I'm very glad that Ming or his people have got in touch - it does show that they're switched on, and prepared to take in a range of views within the party. At the same time, however, I'm a little concerned that he hasn't understood clearly enough what went wrong, and doesn't have a specific plan as to how to nail the coalition question. For my part, I can only suggest that a more direct approach, and a less "political" one, would do a tremendous amount of good here.
Ming should heed his own words. "More of the same" isn't good enough for Britain, and it isn't good enough for us either.
--
I've just blogged three times in a row on exactly the same speech. This can't be healthy! I'd better find something juicy and different to get my teeth into for the next article.
--
What do people think of the new, dynamic header at the top of the page? Is it an improvement, and does it spice up the look of the blog? Or is it just a distraction? All comments appreciated. This is still a bit of an experiment ...
Our technologically-savvy leader, or one of his technologically-savvy office staff, has very kindly written me a response, via Facebook. For readers who aren't familiar with this august website, it's a social networking system, originally for students but now open to everyone. Several of our MPs have Facebook profiles, which may well help with campaigning.
So what did the pinstriped radical have to say for himself?
Firstly, he assured me that he wasn't interested in campaigning for a hung Parliament or a coalition, and that he was still focused on maximising our votes and seats. I agree with him, and I'm glad to hear him say so - but it doesn't solve the problem. Whether he intended it or not, his Conference speech has been widely seen as a coalition overture to Labour. However sincerely he means it when he talks about "maximum votes", that line will no longer stop speculation. Not in the way that it did a fortnight ago.
In his reply, Ming quoted a section from his Conference speech, and complained that it hadn't been taken into account by the newspapers in their analysis. It comes just before the infamous five tests:
And now we are faced with the prospect of Gordon Brown as prime minister.
This Chancellor of the Exchequer has had more control over the direction of government policy than any Chancellor in living memory.
This man, who has written the cheques since 1997, has had unparalleled influence within Whitehall. Why on earth should we believe that Britain will be better governed if he moves from No 11 Downing Street to No. 10?
Why should we believe that more of the same is what Britain needs?
As far as it goes, this is all true. But I would direct Sir Ming to Stephen Tall's excellent article on the subject. Stephen points out that Ming "clumsily set out five tests for Labour’s Gordon Brown to prove his prime ministerial worthiness, but scornfully dismissed David Cameron’s Tories in just three words".
Ming may well claim to have provided a balance between courting Brown and criticising his record - but what happened to the correct balance between criticism of Labour, and criticism of the Tories? That's the balance he got wrong, and that's what led to the damaging speculation.
I suspect (and I have no inside knowledge) that Ming is very unimpressed by David Cameron, and intensely dislikes him. But I worry that he lets his personal contempt colour his political judgement. As my favourite fluffy elephant rightly pointed out, instead of writing him off in three words, Ming should have set some tests for Cameron as well:
The true tests for the Conservatories surely should be the SAME, but with ONE MORE: have some policies so that we can TELL whether you have changed or not!
On the one hand, I'm very glad that Ming or his people have got in touch - it does show that they're switched on, and prepared to take in a range of views within the party. At the same time, however, I'm a little concerned that he hasn't understood clearly enough what went wrong, and doesn't have a specific plan as to how to nail the coalition question. For my part, I can only suggest that a more direct approach, and a less "political" one, would do a tremendous amount of good here.
Ming should heed his own words. "More of the same" isn't good enough for Britain, and it isn't good enough for us either.
--
I've just blogged three times in a row on exactly the same speech. This can't be healthy! I'd better find something juicy and different to get my teeth into for the next article.
--
What do people think of the new, dynamic header at the top of the page? Is it an improvement, and does it spice up the look of the blog? Or is it just a distraction? All comments appreciated. This is still a bit of an experiment ...
Friday, 9 March 2007
How Ming should tackle the hung Parliament question
Until last week, Ming Campbell had a fantastic get-out line whenever he was asked about a hung Parliament. He would say that he was only interested in "maximum votes and maximum seats" for the Liberal Democrats. And that helped to stop our campaigning being derailed by speculation about something which, if it occurs at all, is a good couple of years off.
Conservative blogger Iain Dale believes that, after Harrogategate, the "maximum votes" line will no longer work. Apparently, the Lib Dems are in for a rocky ride during the next few months, and we're going to hear the same question asked ever more loudly. In Iain's view, we need a more convincing answer if we're going to escape without any more harm.
The truth is, we are making a total dog's dinner of the coalition question. There's a much simpler way of doing things; one which will hopefully show the whole question up for the redundant timewaster it really is.
Ming is apparently going to make a speech at the Welsh Conference this weekend. The BBC appears to have the full text in advance. He's going to stress the importance of proportional representation to the party. But if he wanted to undo the damage of last week, and end the speculation about his views on Gordon Brown, he might also say the following:
"A hung Parliament is a very rare event. It last happened in 1974, and then only for eight months. It would be very foolish for a political party to base its strategy on a hung Parliament, and I want to make this very clear: the Lib Dems under my leadership will not be aiming for, or campaigning for, a hung Parliament. We'll keep our feet on the ground, and concentrate on the issues we care about - a fairer, safer society, in a Britain that is both prosperous and environmentally aware. We've put forward radical and innovative policies to bring that about, and that's what I want to talk about.
"But there is still a certain chance of a hung Parliament at the next election. It's not likely, but there's a greater chance now than there has been for a while. Many people have asked me whether the Lib Dems would be more likely to support Labour or the Tories, if we held the balance of power. And although I hate the idea of speculating about something that will probably never happen, I think it's only fair to set out my thoughts.
"The truth is, I can't endorse either Labour or the Tories. I don't believe either of them has the right answers for Britain. They both have their strengths, and I could name quite a few Tory and Labour MPs for whom I have a great deal of respect. But I don't believe either party has what it takes to govern well, which is why the Liberal Democrats stand against Labour and the Tories, and put ourselves forward as an alternative.
"British people deserve a strong Government, and my party has no desire to hold Parliament to ransom. It's probably fair to say that no party can speak for literally everyone, so in a mature, adult democracy, we should be capable of working together for the common good.
"If there were to be a hung Parliament after the next General Election, this is exactly what I would do:
"I would look very closely at the results of the election, and at the national debate. I'd speak to my constituents, and I'd spend time visiting different parts of the UK. I would try my best to build up the best possible image of what British voters want, and what they were trying to say when they voted the way they did.
"And then I would sit down and talk with both David Cameron and with Gordon Brown. I would be open-minded, and go in without any prejudices - but I would always bear in mind the liberal principles and policies of our manifesto. Most of all, I would bear in mind the views and needs of the British people, who deserve a strong and capable Government. I would try my hardest to thrash out a programme of legislation that reflected those needs. If I could achieve that, with either of the other parties, then - and only then - would I agree to enter Government.
"As a Liberal Democrat, I don't believe that politicians should do deals behind closed doors. Mr Brown and Mr Cameron should be under no illusions. If the Lib Dems agreed to a coalition, we would insist on explaining to the public exactly what we had agreed on, and exactly what compromises we'd had to make. We'd also insist on being honest with the public about what the disagreements were, what things we'd agreed to leave on one side until the next election for the sake of stability.
"People in this country can vote Liberal Democrat with confidence. They know that a strong Lib Dem contingent in Parliament will fight for liberal, social and environmental policies, come what may. And they can be certain that in a hung Parliament, we would stick to our principles, we would be faithful to our manifesto, and we would listen to their message. On my watch, if people vote Lib Dem, they know exactly what they're getting."
--
Apologies for the speechwriting gimmick. In my defence, I'm not the only one. David Cameron, Tony Blair and Chucky Kennedy have had to suffer "should-have-said" speeches written for them, by bloggers, by pundits, and even by the general public!
Conservative blogger Iain Dale believes that, after Harrogategate, the "maximum votes" line will no longer work. Apparently, the Lib Dems are in for a rocky ride during the next few months, and we're going to hear the same question asked ever more loudly. In Iain's view, we need a more convincing answer if we're going to escape without any more harm.
The truth is, we are making a total dog's dinner of the coalition question. There's a much simpler way of doing things; one which will hopefully show the whole question up for the redundant timewaster it really is.
Ming is apparently going to make a speech at the Welsh Conference this weekend. The BBC appears to have the full text in advance. He's going to stress the importance of proportional representation to the party. But if he wanted to undo the damage of last week, and end the speculation about his views on Gordon Brown, he might also say the following:
"A hung Parliament is a very rare event. It last happened in 1974, and then only for eight months. It would be very foolish for a political party to base its strategy on a hung Parliament, and I want to make this very clear: the Lib Dems under my leadership will not be aiming for, or campaigning for, a hung Parliament. We'll keep our feet on the ground, and concentrate on the issues we care about - a fairer, safer society, in a Britain that is both prosperous and environmentally aware. We've put forward radical and innovative policies to bring that about, and that's what I want to talk about.
"But there is still a certain chance of a hung Parliament at the next election. It's not likely, but there's a greater chance now than there has been for a while. Many people have asked me whether the Lib Dems would be more likely to support Labour or the Tories, if we held the balance of power. And although I hate the idea of speculating about something that will probably never happen, I think it's only fair to set out my thoughts.
"The truth is, I can't endorse either Labour or the Tories. I don't believe either of them has the right answers for Britain. They both have their strengths, and I could name quite a few Tory and Labour MPs for whom I have a great deal of respect. But I don't believe either party has what it takes to govern well, which is why the Liberal Democrats stand against Labour and the Tories, and put ourselves forward as an alternative.
"British people deserve a strong Government, and my party has no desire to hold Parliament to ransom. It's probably fair to say that no party can speak for literally everyone, so in a mature, adult democracy, we should be capable of working together for the common good.
"If there were to be a hung Parliament after the next General Election, this is exactly what I would do:
"I would look very closely at the results of the election, and at the national debate. I'd speak to my constituents, and I'd spend time visiting different parts of the UK. I would try my best to build up the best possible image of what British voters want, and what they were trying to say when they voted the way they did.
"And then I would sit down and talk with both David Cameron and with Gordon Brown. I would be open-minded, and go in without any prejudices - but I would always bear in mind the liberal principles and policies of our manifesto. Most of all, I would bear in mind the views and needs of the British people, who deserve a strong and capable Government. I would try my hardest to thrash out a programme of legislation that reflected those needs. If I could achieve that, with either of the other parties, then - and only then - would I agree to enter Government.
"As a Liberal Democrat, I don't believe that politicians should do deals behind closed doors. Mr Brown and Mr Cameron should be under no illusions. If the Lib Dems agreed to a coalition, we would insist on explaining to the public exactly what we had agreed on, and exactly what compromises we'd had to make. We'd also insist on being honest with the public about what the disagreements were, what things we'd agreed to leave on one side until the next election for the sake of stability.
"People in this country can vote Liberal Democrat with confidence. They know that a strong Lib Dem contingent in Parliament will fight for liberal, social and environmental policies, come what may. And they can be certain that in a hung Parliament, we would stick to our principles, we would be faithful to our manifesto, and we would listen to their message. On my watch, if people vote Lib Dem, they know exactly what they're getting."
--
Apologies for the speechwriting gimmick. In my defence, I'm not the only one. David Cameron, Tony Blair and Chucky Kennedy have had to suffer "should-have-said" speeches written for them, by bloggers, by pundits, and even by the general public!
Labels:
elections,
hung Parliament,
Iain Dale,
Ming Campbell
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

